In a stunning, and troubling, development U.S. diplomacy has taken a detour into the heart of Europe’s last dictatorship. The June 21 release of 14 political prisoners from Belarus, including opposition leader Siarhei Tsikhanouski, came not from moral pressure or democratic principles, but from a high-level backroom deal brokered by Donald Trump’s envoy, Keith Kellogg.
Make no mistake: this was not a triumph of freedom. This was a trade. And the currency? Legitimacy, sanctions, and geopolitical leverage, all handed to Alexander Lukashenko, the man who has jailed thousands, rigged elections, tortured protesters, and allowed Russian troops to invade Ukraine from his soil.
Welcome to hostage diplomacy, Trump-style.
A Showy Release, A Dirty Deal
Keith Kellogg’s trip to Minsk was the highest U.S. contact with Lukashenko in years. His visit wasn’t an isolated gesture. It followed months of quiet diplomacy that started under the Biden administration, including the release of smaller batches of prisoners. But what made this particular move explosive was not just the visibility, it was who was freed and what was left unsaid.
Among the released were Belarusian opposition icon Siarhei Tsikhanouski, former RFE/RL journalist Ihar Karnei, and citizens of Poland, Estonia, Latvia, the U.S., Sweden, and Japan. They were quietly whisked to Lithuania. Donald Trump immediately claimed credit, parading it as evidence of his “peace through strength” doctrine.
But let’s be clear: Lukashenko didn’t suddenly develop a conscience. He wants something. And the U.S. knows it.
What Does the Dictator Want?
Lukashenko, who has ruled Belarus with an iron grip since 1994, is an international pariah, a war enabler, Putin puppet, and mass oppressor. But with his economy in tatters from U.S. and EU sanctions, he’s desperate. The recent releases weren’t a sign of good faith. They were calculated moves meant to pressure the U.S. into restoring diplomatic ties and lifting crushing sanctions.
His wishlist is long:
- Sanctions relief on Belaruskali, the state-owned potash producer once responsible for 18% of global supply. Belarus’s share has since collapsed to 8%.
- Financial leniency for Belarusian banks blocked from SWIFT and international payments.
- Unfreezing the aircraft fleet of Belarus’s national airline Belavia — including planes used personally by Lukashenko.
In return? A few high-profile prisoners. Not justice. Not reform. Just a PR stunt meant to test how cheap Western values really are.
Trump the “Deal-Maker”: Selling Out Principles for Optics
It’s no secret Trump thrives on spectacle. And in the absence of real wins in Ukraine, he seems happy to manufacture smaller victories wherever he can, even if it means laundering the reputation of a dictator.
In a press conference, Tsikhanouski himself, just freed from five years of unjust imprisonment, pleaded:
“President Trump now has the power and opportunity to free all political prisoners in Belarus just like that. And I ask him to do so.”
Let’s pause here. A man jailed and tortured by a brutal regime now looks to Donald Trump, not the EU, not the UN, but Trump, as the man who holds the keys to Belarus’s political prisons.
And perhaps he’s right. Trump, in his obsession with strongmen, has now inserted himself directly into the region’s geopolitical fabric. Belarusian state media even hinted that Kellogg wasn’t the real leader of the U.S. delegation, suggesting someone even higher ranked, perhaps John Coale or Trump-linked operatives, led the charge.
Coale is no diplomat. He’s a wealthy American lawyer, longtime conservative political donor, and husband of former Fox News anchor Greta Van Susteren. Over the years, he has aligned himself with far-right causes and Trumpworld loyalists. Now, suddenly, he’s showing up in Minsk.
Coale reportedly led the May negotiations that secured the release of dual U.S.-Belarusian citizen Yuras Ziankovich. His presence in such a high-stakes geopolitical flashpoint raises serious questions: What exactly is his mandate? Who does he answer to? And why is shadow diplomacy being run by Trump-linked insiders instead of U.S. foreign service professionals?
This isn’t statecraft. It’s a PR stunt dressed in diplomatic clothing with unofficial actors wielding influence normally reserved for government officials.
Meanwhile, Trump is happy to play kingmaker.
A Thaw or a Trap?
So what is this? A thaw in U.S.-Belarus relations? Or a trap?
Christopher W. Smith, the U.S. Deputy Assistant Secretary of State, called it “a special operation” and teased a “grand bargain”: more prisoner releases in exchange for the lifting of sanctions. His meetings with Lukashenko included talk of scaling back repression and restoring limited diplomatic ties.
But Smith also noted that Lukashenko seemed “confident and in full control.” The dictator is not on the ropes. He’s playing chess.
And Trump? He’s playing TV president again desperate for a foreign policy win, no matter how hollow or morally bankrupt.
Europe Isn’t Buying It
The EU remains skeptical and rightly so. Lithuanian Foreign Minister Kęstutis Budrys dismissed any talk of sanctions relief, saying nothing has fundamentally changed. Meanwhile, Lithuania is working on national sanctions to block Belarusian potash and banking interests, even if Hungary or Slovakia veto EU-wide action.
The message from Vilnius and Brussels is clear:
You don’t bribe a dictator into behaving. You pressure him until he breaks.
Lukashenko’s Legacy: Repression as Strategy
This isn’t the first time Lukashenko has used human lives as bargaining chips. Over 30 years, he’s repeatedly arrested, tortured, and “pardoned” political opponents when it suits him. Cosmetic gestures in exchange for sanctions relief are his go-to tactic.
Former diplomat Pavel Latushka calls it out bluntly:
“Over the 30 years of his rule, Lukashenko has repeatedly used this scheme.. Sanctions should be eased only after the release of all political prisoners, a halt to repression, and the decriminalization of political life.”
Anything less is just playing into his hands.
Conclusion: Don’t Be Fooled
This isn’t a diplomatic success. It’s a political theater, starring Donald Trump as the dealmaker, Lukashenko as the misunderstood strongman, and over a thousand political prisoners as expendable props.
If the West takes the bait, it risks legitimizing not only Lukashenko, but every dictator who learns that jailing innocents can be profitable if you release them at the right moment.
Belarus won’t be free until Lukashenko falls. And Lukashenko won’t fall until we stop rewarding him for temporary mercy while he builds permanent tyranny.
If you appreciate sharp, independent reporting that cuts through the fog of propaganda and PR, consider supporting my work:
👉 ☕ Buy me a coffee
Because dictators don’t rest and neither should the truth.
About the Author
